Political Campaigns: Evolution Since The 20Th Century

how have political campaigns changed since the early 20th century

Political campaigns have changed significantly since the early 20th century. In the 19th century, candidates were expected to remain passive and disinterested, with any campaigning done by local supporters through parades, rallies, and speeches by surrogates. The 1896 campaign between William Jennings Bryan and William McKinley changed the style of campaigning, and by the early 20th century, candidates were openly asking for contributions and directly soliciting votes. The early 20th century also saw the rise of new technologies such as radio, which was used by candidates to reach a wider audience and circumvent partisan newspapers. Additionally, the early 20th century saw the formation of political action committees (PACs) and continued racial discrimination at the polls, with the Texas Democratic Party banning Black Americans from voting in primary elections until a Supreme Court ruling in 1944.

Characteristics Values
Campaign Style 19th-century campaigns were marked by reticence, with candidates believing it was unseemly to praise themselves. In the 20th century, this shifted to enthusiastic public stumping, with candidates directly addressing the nation.
Voter Franchise In the early 19th century, most free adult white males could vote. Over time, the voting franchise expanded, with states removing or reducing property and tax qualifications for suffrage.
Role of Technology The 19th century saw the rise of partisan newspapers as a primary means of communication. The 20th century introduced the radio, which became a powerful tool for political campaigns, with Roosevelt's "fireside chats" reaching tens of millions of listeners.
Campaign Financing In the 18th and early 19th centuries, candidates financed their own campaigns and considered it inappropriate to ask for contributions. Over time, campaigns became increasingly financed by the people, with politicians soliciting contributions.
Political Parties In the 19th century, political parties structured themselves like armies, with a militaristic chain of command. By the early 20th century, the landscape was dominated by two major parties, enlisting most voters into loyal "armies" of supporters.
Campaign Strategies In the 19th century, candidates often refrained from giving partisan or policy-oriented speeches. In the 20th century, campaigns became more rhetorical, with Woodrow Wilson credited for bringing "the rhetorical presidency" and "the rhetorical campaign."

cycivic

The emergence of new technologies and mass media

The internet introduced cost-effective online advertising, enabling political parties to reach a wide audience with targeted messages. The 1996 presidential campaigns of Bill Clinton and Bob Dole were the first to utilize the internet, and since then, technology has played an increasingly prominent role in elections worldwide. Social media platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter, have become indispensable tools for candidates to connect with voters, share their platforms, and engage with the public. These platforms have also facilitated the rise of "micro-politics," marked by issue-based appeals, the influence of celebrity endorsements, and the promotion of minority interests.

The impact of social media on political campaigns has sparked debates about its potential benefits and drawbacks. On the one hand, social media has been credited with making political gatherings more accessible and engaging, providing a space for voters to connect with diverse communities and engage in political discussions. Additionally, platforms like Facebook have introduced features such as the "I Voted" button, which has been shown to boost voter turnout.

However, the use of social media in political campaigns has also raised concerns about the spread of misinformation and the potential for manipulation. The Cambridge Analytica scandal, for example, brought to light the potential for micro-targeting voters based on their personality traits and the spread of fake news. This has led to increased calls for social media companies to develop rigorous fact-checking and verification processes to combat the dissemination of false information.

Furthermore, the influence of technology in political campaigns extends beyond social media. Digital technologies, such as email, websites, and texting, have become essential tools for fundraising, volunteer registration, and communicating with voters. The evolution of digital campaigns has also given rise to the influence of micro-influencers, individuals who, while not affiliated with political parties, possess significant influence over their online followers. These micro-influencers can play a crucial role in shaping political discourse and connecting with younger and diverse communities.

cycivic

The role of partisan newspapers and their influence on public opinion

Partisan newspapers played a significant role in political campaigns in the early 20th century, shaping public opinion and serving as the primary medium for mass communication. Nearly all weekly and daily papers were affiliated with a particular political party until the early 1900s, marking the first communications system for political campaigns. These partisan newspapers actively slanted their news coverage to favor their affiliated party and disparage opposing parties. They were effective tools for disseminating party platforms, biographies of candidates, and selected speeches.

The proliferation of newspapers during this period was driven by the emergence of high-speed presses and free postage for rural sheets. The 1850 Census counted 1,630 partisan newspapers, with a circulation of about one per voter, compared to only 83 "independent" papers. Editors of these partisan newspapers were often senior party leaders, and top publishers were sometimes nominated on the national ticket, blurring the lines between media and politics.

The authority and influence of partisan newspapers were such that they could make or break a candidate's campaign. For example, broadsides, cards, and prints depicting candidates were used to capture the attention of literate voters and influence their choices. Additionally, newspapers would publish detailed information about a party's platform, selectively highlight specific speeches, and use editorial content to promote their party's triumphs and criticize opponents.

However, with the advent of new technologies in the early 20th century, the landscape of political campaigns began to shift. The invention of the radio presented a formidable challenge to the supremacy of newspapers in mass media. The radio's ability to reach a nationwide audience simultaneously made it an attractive tool for political campaigns. Roosevelt, for example, effectively used radio to address the nation directly, dispel rumors, and clarify his policies, circumventing the Republican-dominated newspaper scene.

The transition from partisan newspapers to radio as the primary medium for political campaigns marked a significant change in how candidates engaged with the public. The shift from printed word to spoken word, from static images to dynamic broadcasts, and from selective news coverage to direct addresses, transformed the nature of political campaigns and the relationship between candidates and voters.

cycivic

The evolution of campaign strategies and the use of personal attacks

Political campaigns have evolved significantly since the early 20th century, with candidates embracing new technologies and adapting their strategies to connect with voters. One notable aspect of this evolution is the changing nature of campaign strategies and the use of personal attacks.

In the early 20th century, the landscape of political campaigns was dominated by partisan newspapers, which served as the primary means of communication between candidates and voters. These newspapers were strongly aligned with specific political parties, and their editors were often senior party leaders. The content of these publications was heavily slanted, praising the party's triumphs and criticising the opposition. This era also witnessed the emergence of broadsides, cards, and prints depicting candidates from all parties, sold by commercial publishers to capture the attention of literate voters.

However, with the advent of new technologies in the 20th century, campaigns began to utilise radio broadcasting as a powerful tool for reaching voters directly. American Telephone and Telegraph Company, or AT&T, played a pivotal role in this transformation by selling radio broadcasting time for commercial use. The impact of radio was profound, as it allowed candidates to circumvent partisan newspapers and speak directly to the nation. Roosevelt's "fireside chats" during World War II are a prime example of this shift, where he addressed domestic recovery efforts and military actions, effectively shaping public opinion and dispelling rumours.

The introduction of radio also marked a turning point in the style of campaigning. While 19th-century candidates like James Polk and Martin Van Buren believed it was unbecoming to praise oneself, the 20th century witnessed a shift towards enthusiastic public stumping. Woodrow Wilson, in particular, is credited with revolutionising campaigns by engaging in a full-scale speaking tour, ushering in the era of rhetorical campaigns.

Despite the evolution of campaign strategies, personal attacks have long been a feature of political campaigns. As early as 1832, Henry Clay commissioned a poster of his opponent, Andrew Jackson, to remind voters of the escaped British monarchy, mirroring Jackson's frequent use of the veto. Such vitriolic and personal attacks set a precedent for later presidential campaigns, where candidates would employ similar tactics to discredit their opponents.

In summary, the evolution of campaign strategies since the early 20th century has been characterised by the adoption of new technologies, a shift from partisan newspapers to radio broadcasts, and a move towards more enthusiastic and rhetorical campaigning. While personal attacks have always been a part of political campaigns, the nature and reach of these attacks have been amplified by the changing media landscape.

cycivic

The impact of racial discrimination and the expansion of voting rights

Political campaigns in the early 20th century were influenced by the ongoing struggle for racial equality and the expansion of voting rights in the United States. While formal racial discrimination was largely banned by the mid-20th century, the early decades of the century saw a hardening of institutionalised racism and legal discrimination against African Americans. This had a significant impact on political campaigns and the ongoing battle for voting rights.

The history of voting rights in the US has been marked by the struggle of women, the formerly enslaved, and native peoples to secure and maintain the right to vote. The early 20th century saw the culmination of these efforts, with the ratification of the 19th Amendment in 1920, granting women the right to vote nationwide. However, racial discrimination and voter suppression tactics persisted, particularly in the Southern states, targeting African Americans.

Since the nation's founding, voting rights were nearly exclusive to propertied white men. Over time, voting rights expanded, but this progress was often met with resistance and efforts to suppress the vote. In the early 20th century, Southern states employed tactics such as poll taxes, literacy tests, intimidation, and violence to disenfranchise African American men. Poll taxes, which required voters to pay money to vote, were especially detrimental to African Americans and low-income white voters. Literacy tests were also used as a barrier, despite African American men being literate enough to read campaign posters and newspapers.

The expansion of voting rights in the early 20th century was a result of activism and legislative action. The Reconstruction period following the Civil War led to the passage of the 15th Amendment, ensuring that the right to vote could not be denied based on race. However, it took decades of activism and legal battles to overcome discriminatory practices and fully realise the promise of this amendment. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 was a landmark legislation that took significant steps towards ending voter suppression.

The early 20th century also witnessed the decline of national Black politics due to racial discrimination in federal offices. During the presidency of Woodrow Wilson, administrative policies combining progressive politics and white supremacy diminished the political power and economic opportunities of African Americans. This period saw the rise of white supremacist groups like the Ku Klux Klan, who intimidated Black voters and contributed to the suppression of Black votes in the South.

In conclusion, the early 20th century was a pivotal period in the expansion of voting rights, particularly for women and racial minorities. While legal barriers to voting were gradually dismantled, racial discrimination and voter suppression tactics persisted, shaping the political campaigns and continuing the struggle for equal voting rights in America.

cycivic

The influence of political action committees (PACs) and campaign finance laws

Political action committees (PACs) and campaign finance laws have had a significant influence on the evolution of political campaigns in the United States. The concept of candidates actively fundraising and soliciting contributions from constituents would have been foreign to politicians like George Washington in the 18th and early 19th centuries. Wealthy and well-connected candidates of that era typically financed their own campaigns and considered it unseemly to openly ask for donations.

However, as democracy expanded and the voting franchise was enlarged in the early 19th century, political campaigns became more accessible to candidates without privileged backgrounds, such as Andrew Jackson, who is often associated with the emergence of fundraising and campaigning as we know it today. During the Jackson presidency and the decades that followed, elections increasingly relied on financial contributions from the people, and those in power did not hesitate to solicit donations aggressively. This led to abuses, such as the political patronage system, where government positions and favours were exchanged for campaign contributions, creating an environment where government roles were effectively up for sale.

In response to these issues, Congress passed the Naval Appropriations Bill in 1867, prohibiting federal government officers and employees from soliciting money for political campaigns from naval yard workers. Despite this legislation, the political patronage system persisted throughout the 19th century. It wasn't until the 20th century that we see the formation of PACs as a result of legislation prohibiting direct contributions from labour unions, trade organizations, and special interest groups to political parties and campaigns. These groups then created PACs, voluntary associations that raised funds from individual members to support specific candidates.

The influence of PACs and campaign finance laws continued to shape political campaigns, with a notable example being the Publicity (Federal Corrupt Practices) Act. In 1921, former Michigan Senator Truman H. Newberry was convicted of violating federal campaign finance law under this Act. However, the Supreme Court ruled that Congress lacked the authority to regulate spending and other aspects of party primaries or conventions related to candidate nominations. This decision set a precedent and had implications for future campaign finance practices.

The shift from the reticence of 19th-century campaigns to the enthusiastic public stumping of the 20th century is also worth noting. This transformation is exemplified by Woodrow Wilson, who was the first victorious presidential candidate to engage in a full-scale speaking tour during his campaign, marking a significant departure from the passive and disinterested stance of his predecessors.

Frequently asked questions

In the 19th century, the newspaper was the primary medium for political campaigns, with nearly all weekly and daily papers being party organs. However, by the early 20th century, the radio had emerged as a new technology that would eventually render the newspaper obsolete. Political campaigns in the early 20th century began to utilize the radio to reach a wider audience and circumvent partisan newspapers.

In the 19th century, presidential candidates often feigned disinterest in campaigning, believing it to be unseemly to praise oneself. However, in the 20th century, candidates enthusiastically embraced public stumping and speaking tours, marking a shift towards a more rhetorical style of campaigning.

In the 19th century, wealthy and well-connected candidates often financed their own campaigns, and it was considered inappropriate for candidates to directly solicit donations from constituents. However, by the early 20th century, organizations known as political action committees (PACs) emerged to raise funds from individual members for specific candidates. Additionally, racial discrimination at the polls was addressed, with the Supreme Court ruling in 1944 that racial discrimination in primary elections was unconstitutional.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment