Founding Fathers' Approach To Slavery In The Constitution

The issue of slavery proved to be a difficult one for the Founding Fathers to navigate. Many of the Founding Fathers were slaveholders themselves, and nearly half of the delegates to the Constitutional Convention owned slaves. Despite this, many expressed a desire to see the institution gradually abolished. The Founding Fathers' beliefs about slavery were shaped by the context of their time: they had been born into a slaveholding society, and the American Revolution and the spread of Enlightenment ideals brought the issue of slavery to the fore, eventually resulting in vast regional and political divides. The Founding Fathers addressed slavery in the Constitution through a series of clauses that acknowledged regional differences and required compromises from all sections of the new country.

Explore related products

Dred Scott and the Politics of Slavery (Landmark Law Cases and American Society)

$24.99 $29.99

Born Equal: Remaking America’s Constitution, 1840–1920

$36.96 $40

Creating a More Perfect Slaveholders' Union: Slavery, the Constitution, and Secession in Antebellum America (Constitutional Thinking)

$32.71 $59.99

The Laws of Slavery in Texas: Historical Documents and Essays (Texas Legal Studies Series)

$19.36 $19.95

Slavery and the Supreme Court, 1825-1861

$59.99

Slavery's Constitution: From Revolution to Ratification

$17.1 $19.99

The Founding Fathers' views on slavery

The Founding Fathers of the United States had differing views on slavery, with some morally opposed to it and others attempting to end it in several colonies. However, nationally, slavery remained protected. The institution of slavery was deeply rooted in the American colonies, and many of the Founding Fathers, including George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and James Monroe, owned slaves.

During the era of the Articles of Confederation (1781-1789), the Founding Fathers exhibited considerable aversion to slavery by prohibiting the importation of foreign slaves to individual states and supporting a proposal to ban slavery in the Northwest Territory. However, these policies served the interests of Virginia and Maryland slaveholders, who could sell their slaves southward and westward at higher prices. The ban on slavery in the Northwest also tacitly legitimized the expansion of slavery in the Southwest.

During the Constitutional Convention in 1787, the Founding Fathers debated the issue of slavery, with some voicing eloquent objections to it. James Madison, often referred to as the "Father of the Constitution", attacked slavery early in the Convention, stating that it was based on "the most oppressive dominion ever exercised by man over man". Gouverneur Morris, another vocal opponent of slavery, called it a "nefarious institution" and "the curse of heaven on the States where it prevailed". Despite these objections, the Founding Fathers sidestepped the issue of slavery in the Constitution, prioritizing the unity of the new United States over sectional tensions.

The Three-Fifths Clause in the Constitution, which counted three-fifths of a state's slave population for representation, gave the South extra representation in the House of Representatives and extra votes in the Electoral College. This clause enhanced Southern power in the House and has been interpreted as a protection for slavery. The Founding Fathers also granted a moratorium until 1808 on any congressional ban against the importation of slaves, allowing individual states to prohibit slave imports if they wished.

While some Founding Fathers, such as Thomas Jefferson, wrote about the evils of slavery and wished to see it abolished, they did not take significant steps to end it. Jefferson, for example, never personally freed his slaves, and they were sold off after his death to pay off his debts. Other Founding Fathers, such as Benjamin Franklin, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay, were members of anti-slavery societies and worked to gradually abolish slavery in their states.

In summary, the Founding Fathers' views on slavery were complex and varied. While some morally opposed it and made efforts to contain it, others accommodated it to maintain national unity and protect their economic interests. The institution of slavery proved challenging for them to navigate, and their inability to address it effectively left a legacy of racial inequality and division in the United States.

Slavery in the Constitution

The issue of slavery proved to be a difficult one for the Founding Fathers to navigate. They had been born into a slaveholding society where the morality of owning slaves was rarely questioned. The institution of slavery was protected by law in all 13 American colonies when they declared their independence from Great Britain in 1776. Many of the Founding Fathers, including the authors of the Declaration of Independence, owned slaves.

The Founding Fathers were not unified on the issue of slavery and continued to accommodate it within the new nation. Some were morally opposed to it and some attempted to end it in several of the colonies, but nationally, slavery remained protected. During the war and immediately following it, Northern states began passing laws to gradually abolish slavery in their states. Pennsylvania was the first state to begin the process in 1780, followed by Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Connecticut, and Rhode Island. New York and New Jersey followed in 1799 and 1804, respectively. While these Northern states did not rely on slave labor for their agriculture, their economy was still tied to the exports from the Southern states that did.

The Founding Fathers made some efforts to contain slavery. In 1782, Virginia passed a manumission law that allowed owners to free their slaves by will or deed, resulting in the manumission of thousands of slaves. In 1784, Jefferson proposed to ban slavery in all the western territories, but this failed to pass Congress by one vote. Congress did ban slavery in the Northwest Ordinance, for lands north of the Ohio River. In 1785, John Jay and Alexander Hamilton founded the New York Manumission Society, which established the New York African Free School in 1787.

During the Constitutional Convention in 1787, the Founding Fathers drafted a series of constitutional clauses acknowledging deep-seated regional differences over slavery while requiring all sections of the new country to make compromises. They granted slaveholding states the right to count three-fifths of their slave population when apportioning the number of a state's representatives to Congress, thereby enhancing Southern power in the House of Representatives. This same ratio was used to determine the federal tax contribution required of each state, thus increasing the direct federal tax burden of slaveholding states. The word "slave" was consciously avoided in the Constitution, but it received important protections.

The Founding Fathers' views on slavery were influenced by the ideals of the Enlightenment, which spread through the American colonies in the 1760s and 1770s, and the Revolutionary War. They acknowledged that slavery violated the core American Revolutionary ideal of liberty, but their simultaneous commitment to private property rights, principles of limited government, and intersectional harmony prevented them from making a bold move against slavery.

The three-fifths clause

During the Constitutional Convention, there was a bitter debate over slavery. Some delegates, such as Luther Martin of Maryland, argued that slavery was contrary to American ideals and should be regulated by the federal government. Others, like John Rutledge of South Carolina, threatened to leave the Union if the regulation of slavery was taken out of the hands of individual states.

Explore related products

Enslaved Archives: Slavery, Law, and the Production of the Past

$30.22 $49.95

American Inheritance: Liberty and Slavery in the Birth of a Nation, 1765-1795

$8.19 $32.5

The Sources of Anti-Slavery Constitutionalism in America, 1760-1848

$5 $24.95

Lincoln and Chief Justice Taney: Slavery, Secession, and the President's War Powers (Simon & Schuster Lincoln Library)

$10.29 $16.99

No Property in Man: Slavery and Antislavery at the Nation’s Founding, With a New Preface (The Nathan I. Huggins Lectures)

$22 $14.95

The Interbellum Constitution: Union, Commerce, and Slavery in the Age of Federalisms (Yale Law Library Series in Legal History and Reference)

$36.99 $45

The Founding Fathers' actions against slavery

During the American Revolution and in the years that followed, several Northern states passed laws to abolish or significantly reduce slavery. Pennsylvania was the first state to begin this process in 1780, followed by Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Connecticut, and Rhode Island. New York and New Jersey followed suit in 1799 and 1804, respectively. These Northern states did not heavily rely on slave labour for their agriculture, but their economies were tied to exports from Southern states that did.

The Founding Fathers also made legislative efforts to contain slavery. In 1782, Virginia passed a manumission law that allowed owners to free their slaves by will or deed, leading to the manumission of thousands of slaves in the state. In 1785, John Jay and Alexander Hamilton founded the New York Manumission Society, which established the New York African Free School in 1787. During the Constitutional Convention in 1787, Gouverneur Morris, one of the most vocal opponents of slavery among the Founding Fathers, called it a "nefarious institution" and "the curse of heaven on the States where it prevailed".

The Founding Fathers also acknowledged the deep-seated regional differences over slavery and required all sections of the country to make compromises. They granted slave-holding states representation in Congress based on their total population, including three-fifths of their slave population, which enhanced Southern power in the House of Representatives. However, this same ratio was used to determine the federal tax contribution required from each state, increasing the direct federal tax burden on slave-holding states.

While the Founding Fathers took some actions against slavery, they also made concessions to maintain unity and accommodate the institution within the new nation. They recognised that slavery was a complex issue that contradicted the core American Revolutionary ideal of liberty. Their commitment to private property rights, limited government, and intersectional harmony prevented them from taking more decisive action against slavery.

The Founding Fathers' failure to abolish slavery

Firstly, it is important to recognize that many of the Founding Fathers, including prominent figures such as George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison, owned slaves themselves. This inherent conflict between their ideals of liberty and freedom and their personal investment in slavery made it challenging for them to take decisive action against slavery. While some Founding Fathers, such as Benjamin Franklin and Alexander Hamilton, became members of anti-slavery societies, their efforts were often met with resistance, particularly from Southern Founders who relied heavily on slave-based agriculture.

Secondly, the Founding Fathers were faced with the challenge of unifying a nation with stark regional differences, especially between the Northern and Southern states. The Southern states, including South Carolina and Georgia, threatened to refuse to join the Union if the Constitution restricted the slave trade. As a result, the Founding Fathers made concessions on slavery to maintain national unity, even though they recognized that this would lay the foundation for future conflicts. The three-fifths clause in the Constitution, which granted Southern states enhanced representation based on their slave populations, is a notable example of these concessions.

Additionally, the Founding Fathers' failure to abolish slavery can be attributed to their belief that it was an "evil they knew not well how to deal with." Thomas Jefferson, for instance, recognized the moral and political evils of slavery but felt powerless to change the situation, fearing the consequences of abruptly abolishing the institution. Instead, he and other Founding Fathers took incremental steps, such as proposing to ban slavery in certain territories or supporting gradual abolition in specific states.

The Founding Fathers' inability to address slavery during the drafting of the Constitution had significant ramifications for the future of the nation. It not only perpetuated the institution of slavery but also contributed to the regional and political divides that would eventually lead to the American Civil War. While some scholars argue that the Constitution created a central government powerful enough to eventually abolish slavery, the failure of the Founding Fathers to confront it directly in the nation's founding document remains a significant shortcoming.

In conclusion, the Founding Fathers' failure to abolish slavery was a result of their own complicity in the institution, regional tensions, and a lack of consensus on how to address an issue so deeply rooted in American society. While some Founding Fathers recognized the moral and political evils of slavery, their inability to take decisive action had lasting consequences for the nation's struggle toward equality and justice.

Frequently asked questions