Monroe's Constitutional Legacy: A Founding Father's Impact

James Monroe, the fifth president of the United States, contributed to the Constitution in several ways. Initially, Monroe opposed the Constitution, calling for guarantees of free navigation on the Mississippi River and advocating for direct election of the president and senators. He also wanted to prevent the creation of a standing army and opposed the Electoral College. Despite his opposition, Monroe voted against the ratification of the Constitution, holding out for the inclusion of a bill of rights. However, he eventually supported the document and played a key role in shaping it. Monroe's influence extended beyond the Constitution, as he also helped negotiate the Louisiana Purchase, supported the Missouri Compromise, and established the Monroe Doctrine, which became a significant tenet of US foreign policy in the Western Hemisphere.

Explore related products

James Monroe: The American Presidents Series: The 5th President, 1817-1825

$10.73 $33

The Last Founding Father: James Monroe and a Nation's Call to Greatness

$12.49 $23.99

The Constitution of the United States (U.S. Heritage): with The Declaration of Independence, The Bill of Rights and other Founding Documents with an ... by Constitutional Lawyer Alan Dershowitz

$34.99

The United States Constitution: A Round Table Comic

$12.95 $12.95

The Jeffersonians

$21.72 $30

The Honest Book of Presidents: The Men Who Shaped America

$28.99 $28.99

Monroe opposed the Electoral College

James Monroe, the last American President of the "Virginia Dynasty", was an eyewitness to many of the events that led to the creation of the United States and the U.S. Constitution. Monroe was initially opposed to the ratification of the United States Constitution, calling for it to include guarantees regarding free navigation on the Mississippi River and to give the federal government direct control over the militia in case of defence. He also opposed the Electoral College, believing it to be too corruptible and susceptible to state interests. He favoured the direct election of the president and the inclusion of a bill of rights.

Monroe's opposition to the Electoral College was based on his belief that it was too easily influenced by state interests and was not in the best interests of the country as a whole. He argued that the direct election of the president would be a more democratic process and would better represent the will of the people. This position was in line with his broader support for democratic reforms and his desire to strengthen the bill of rights.

Monroe's views on the Electoral College were not unique, and he was part of a broader movement that advocated for democratic reforms and the reduction of the influence of state interests in the electoral process. This movement gained support across the country, and Monroe's role in advocating for these reforms is recognised as a significant contribution to the democratic process in the United States.

Despite his initial opposition to the Electoral College, Monroe eventually came to accept it as part of the Constitution. However, he continued to advocate for reforms that would strengthen the democratic process and protect the rights of citizens. Monroe's contribution to the Constitution and the development of democracy in the United States is therefore complex and multifaceted.

Monroe's political career spanned several decades and he held numerous important positions, including serving as a delegate to the Continental Congress, a delegate to the Virginia Ratifying Convention, a senator, governor of Virginia, and finally, president of the United States. His presidency, which began in 1817, encompassed what came to be called the "Era of Good Feelings".

Monroe voted against the Constitution's ratification

James Monroe was a Founding Father of the United States and the fifth president of the country, serving from 1817 to 1825. He was an eyewitness to many of the events that led to the creation of the United States and the U.S. Constitution.

Monroe voted against the ratification of the United States Constitution. In 1787, he began serving in the Virginia assembly and was chosen the following year as a delegate to the Virginia Ratifying Convention, which voted on the adoption of the Constitution. He was unable to attend the Philadelphia Convention due to his work obligations.

Monroe opposed the ratification of the Constitution, wanting a strong bill of rights to be included. He voted against ratification, holding out for the direct election of presidents and senators. He also opposed the Electoral College, viewing it as too corruptible and susceptible to state interests.

Partly due to politicians like Monroe, who brought attention to the omission of such constitutional guarantees, the Bill of Rights became the first ten amendments of the Constitution upon ratification in 1791. Monroe eventually supported the document.

Monroe's presidency encompassed what came to be called the "Era of Good Feelings." One of his lasting achievements was the Monroe Doctrine, which became a major tenet of U.S. foreign policy in the Western Hemisphere, aiming to limit European colonialism in the Americas.

He supported a bill of rights

James Monroe was an eyewitness to many of the events that led to the creation of the United States and the U.S. Constitution. Monroe studied law under Thomas Jefferson from 1780 to 1783 and served as a delegate to the Continental Congress and the Virginia Ratifying Convention. Notably, Monroe initially opposed the Constitution, wanting a strong bill of rights.

Monroe voted against the ratification of the United States Constitution, holding out for the direct election of presidents and senators and for the inclusion of a bill of rights. He called for the Constitution to include guarantees regarding free navigation on the Mississippi River and to give the federal government direct control over the militia in case of defence. He also opposed the Electoral College, viewing it as too corruptible and susceptible to state interests.

Partly due to politicians like Monroe, who brought attention to the omission of such constitutional guarantees, the Bill of Rights became the first ten amendments of the Constitution upon ratification in 1791. Monroe's support for a bill of rights was therefore a significant contribution to the Constitution.

Monroe's political career was illustrious and he held several key public offices before becoming president in 1817. He was elected governor of Virginia in 1799 and served three one-year terms. He was also a minister to France and England for President Thomas Jefferson and served as secretary of state and secretary of war for President James Madison.

One of Monroe's lasting achievements as president was the Monroe Doctrine, a major tenet of U.S. foreign policy in the Western Hemisphere. The doctrine stated that Europe needed to stay out of the affairs of new countries and territories in the Western Hemisphere, and in exchange, the United States would stay out of Europe.

Explore related products

Makers of American History: James Madison, James Monroe and John Quincy Adams (Classic Reprint)

$34.72

Success of the Calhoun Revolution: The Constitution Changed and Slavery Nationalized by the Usurpations of the Supreme Court

$26.95

The Papers of James Monroe: Selected Correspondence and Papers, 1794–1796, Volume 3

$133.08

James Monroe: In His Relations To The Public Service During Half A Century, 1776 To 1826

$31.95 $14.02

James Monroe, John Marshall and ‘The Excellence of Our Institutions’, 1817–1825 (Routledge Advances in American History)

$190 $53.99

The Monroe Doctrine: Empire and Nation in Nineteenth-Century America

$12.89 $21

Monroe helped negotiate the Louisiana Purchase

James Monroe was a dominant figure in American politics during the early years of the country's existence, serving in almost every key public office before becoming president in 1817. He was a close friend of Thomas Jefferson, and it was during Jefferson's presidency that Monroe helped negotiate the Louisiana Purchase.

In 1803, France had acquired Louisiana from Spain, and President Thomas Jefferson feared that Napoleon Bonaparte would revive the French empire in the New World. Louisiana was a valuable sugar colony, and France intended to use it as the granary for its empire. Jefferson sent Monroe to join Robert Livingston in France to try to purchase New Orleans and West Florida for as much as $10 million. Monroe joined Livingston in Paris on April 12, 1803, and they found Napoleon willing to dispose of the entire province of Louisiana. On May 2, 1803, they signed a treaty and two conventions (antedated to April 30) whereby France sold Louisiana to the United States for $15 million.

The Louisiana Purchase encompassed 530,000,000 acres of territory in North America, and it nearly doubled the size of the United States. The territory made up all or part of fifteen modern U.S. states between the Mississippi River and the Rocky Mountains. The purchase was a significant achievement for the Jefferson administration, and Monroe was perceived as a national hero for his role in it.

Monroe continued to serve his government in Europe after the Louisiana Purchase, representing the United States as the minister to Britain from 1803 to 1807, with a brief stint as a special envoy to Spain in 1805. He also played a key role in the run-up to the War of 1812, using his experience as a British diplomat to win the backing of the "War Hawks" for administration policies.

He opposed the Jay Treaty

James Monroe was a key figure in the early days of the United States, serving as a soldier, diplomat, senator, and cabinet official before becoming the country's president in 1817. During his time in these roles, Monroe played a significant part in shaping the young nation and its policies, including its constitution.

One notable aspect of Monroe's political career was his opposition to the Jay Treaty, also known as the Treaty of Amity, Commerce, and Navigation. This treaty was signed in 1794 between the United States and Great Britain, and it averted war, resolved lingering issues from the Treaty of Paris (1783), and facilitated peaceful trade for a decade. The treaty was designed by Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton and supported by President George Washington.

Monroe, however, took issue with the treaty, and his opposition to it is well-documented. He believed that the US government was too close to Britain, especially regarding the Jay Treaty. This view was shared by his political allies, Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, who also opposed the treaty. They argued for a "direct system of commercial hostility with Great Britain", even if it risked war. Monroe's stance on this matter caused a rift between him and Washington, who had sent Monroe to France as an ambassador. Washington eventually recalled Monroe from his post in 1796 due to his criticism of the treaty.

The Jay Treaty was a compromise between the US and Britain, but it failed to satisfy both major political factions within the US. It embodied the views of the Federalists, led by Hamilton, but was opposed by the Democratic-Republicans, led by Jefferson and Madison. The treaty angered France, a key ally of the Democratic-Republicans, and further divided American public opinion.

Monroe's opposition to the Jay Treaty stemmed from his belief in the need for a strong bill of rights and his preference for supporting France over Britain during the French Revolution. He felt that Britain posed a greater threat to US republican values. As a result of his stance, Monroe played a role in the advent of the First Party System in the US, with the Federalists on one side and the Democratic-Republicans on the other.

In summary, James Monroe's opposition to the Jay Treaty was a significant aspect of his political career. It highlighted his beliefs about the role of government, his commitment to certain ideological principles, and his alliance with Jefferson and Madison. Monroe's stance had consequences for his relationship with Washington and contributed to the growing political divide in the young United States.

Frequently asked questions