Amending The Constitution: Understanding The Revision Process

how are the bylaws of the constitution revised

Constitutions and bylaws are both documents that contain the basic rules relating to an organization. While the constitution forms a statement of existence and establishes the fundamental framework of an organization, bylaws are the written rules that govern a corporation's operations and can be revised as needed to reflect changing realities, expectations, and goals. This article will explore the process of revising the bylaws of the constitution, including the steps, requirements, and potential challenges involved. It will also examine the impact of revisions on an organization's structure and operations, providing insights into effective governance and adaptation to changing circumstances.

Characteristics Values
Difficulty of revision Bylaws are easier to revise than the constitution
Frequency of revision Bylaws can be revised as needed to reflect changing realities, bylaws must be approved annually
Purpose Constitutions contain the most basic rules and structure of the organization, bylaws elaborate the rules that govern a corporation's operations
Topics covered Common bylaw topics include how directors are elected, the role of each director, accounting and finance procedures, dissolution clauses, and rules governing the transfer of shares and ownership
Number of documents It is recommended to combine the constitution and bylaws into a single document, typically called "bylaws"

cycivic

Consolidating the constitution and bylaws into one document

While constitutions and bylaws are distinct documents, some groups may opt to consolidate them into a single instrument. This consolidated document is usually called the ""bylaws", although some organisations may refer to it as the "constitution" or "constitution and bylaws".

The process of consolidating the constitution and bylaws involves combining the basic rules and structure of an organisation into a single document. The constitution typically contains the fundamental framework of an organisation, including its name, head office, purpose, size of the board, number of officers, annual meeting requirements, fiscal year, and definition of members. On the other hand, bylaws elaborate on the rules and procedures that govern the organisation's operations. They cover areas such as how directors are elected, the role of each director, accounting and finance procedures, dissolution clauses, and rules governing the transfer of shares and ownership.

When consolidating the two documents, it is important to ensure that there is no duplication or conflict between the content of the constitution and bylaws. The consolidated document should provide a comprehensive set of rules and procedures that govern the organisation's structure and operations.

It is worth noting that the process of revising the consolidated document may differ from the process of amending the constitution or bylaws individually. In the consolidated document, revisions may be referred to as "revisions" rather than "amendments". The specific process for adopting revisions will depend on the organisation's procedures and requirements.

cycivic

Amending the constitution

The first step in amending the Constitution is proposing an amendment. This can occur in two ways. Firstly, Congress can propose an amendment with a two-thirds majority vote in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. Alternatively, two-thirds of state legislatures can request that Congress call a Constitutional Convention to propose an amendment. It is worth noting that, historically, none of the amendments have been proposed by a Constitutional Convention, and a new convention of this type has never been convened.

Once an amendment is proposed, it must be ratified. The Archivist of the United States, who heads the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), is responsible for administering the ratification process. The specific procedures for ratification are not detailed in the Constitution, but the Archivist follows established customs. The Office of the Federal Register (OFR) plays a crucial role in this process by verifying the required number of authenticated ratification documents. After verification, the OFR drafts a formal proclamation for the Archivist to certify that the amendment is valid.

The certification of a new amendment is a significant event. It is published in the Federal Register and U.S. Statutes at Large, serving as official notice to Congress and the nation that the amendment process is complete. The certification ceremony has become a ceremonial affair, often attended by dignitaries, including the President.

cycivic

Changing bylaws as needed

Bylaws are the written rules that govern the structure and operations of an organisation or corporation. They are distinct from a constitution, which establishes the fundamental framework of an organisation, and are typically more detailed and focused on operational rules. While constitutions are deliberately made difficult to change, bylaws can be revised as needed to reflect changing realities, expectations, and goals.

The process of changing bylaws can vary, but it typically involves creating a new document that replaces the existing bylaws. This process may be referred to as a "`revision," rather than an "amendment." In some cases, organisations may choose to consolidate their constitution and bylaws into a single document, which can reduce potential duplication or conflict between the two. However, it is important to note that the process of changing bylaws should be marginally less difficult than amending the constitution.

The specific steps to revise bylaws can depend on the organisation and its governing procedures. In general, it is recommended to provide notice of the proposed changes and seek approval from a majority of the members or a designated decision-making body. Some organisations may have specific requirements for amending bylaws, such as a higher vote threshold or the involvement of a governing body. It is essential to refer to the organisation's constitution, parliamentary authority, or established procedures to ensure compliance with the required processes.

The content of the revised bylaws will depend on the specific needs and nature of the organisation. Common topics addressed in bylaws include the election of directors, the role of each director, accounting and financial procedures, dissolution clauses, rules governing the transfer of shares and ownership, disciplinary procedures, and day-to-day operational policies. It is important to ensure that the revised bylaws are properly kept and maintained, as they can be referenced in dispute resolution and legal cases involving the organisation.

cycivic

Rules and policies for conducting day-to-day business

Bylaws are the written rules that govern the structure and internal management of a corporation's operations. They are distinct from the articles of incorporation, which are primarily concerned with the establishment of a corporation. While the articles of incorporation are crucial during the initial stages of a corporation's existence, bylaws are more relevant to its day-to-day functioning.

Bylaws can be revised as needed to reflect changing realities, expectations, and goals. They are typically more flexible and easier to amend than the constitution, which is designed to be a stable framework for the organisation. The process of amending bylaws may vary, but it commonly involves providing notice and securing a higher-than-majority vote, such as a two-thirds majority.

The content of bylaws can include a range of topics related to the internal management of the corporation. Common bylaw subjects include the election and roles of directors, accounting and financial procedures, rules governing the transfer of shares and ownership, dissolution clauses, and operational rules for conducting day-to-day business. Day-to-day business operations outlined in the bylaws might include specific policies and procedures relevant to the organisation's activities.

For example, in the context of a local sports league, bylaws might cover tournament team selection methods, local rules, and age structure. In a corporate setting, bylaws could outline procedures for procurement, human resources, customer service, and sales, depending on the nature of the business. It is essential to tailor the bylaws to the specific needs and nature of the organisation.

While some organisations choose to maintain separate constitution and bylaw documents, others prefer to consolidate them into a single governing instrument. In the consolidated form, the document is typically referred to as "'bylaws.'" The benefit of a single document is the reduction of potential duplication or conflict between the constitution and bylaws.

cycivic

Common bylaw topics

Bylaws are a set of rules or laws established by an organization or community to regulate itself, with the degree of control exercised being determined by a higher authority, such as a legislature or government body. Bylaws often vary from organization to organization, but some common topics they cover include:

  • The purpose of the organization: This includes the organization's objectives and basic purposes.
  • Membership: Bylaws may outline who the members of the organization are and how directors are elected.
  • Meetings: This includes how meetings are conducted, such as the frequency and format of meetings.
  • Officers and their duties: Bylaws may describe the officers of the organization and outline their specific roles and responsibilities.
  • Parliamentary authority: This refers to the rules and procedures that govern the organization's decision-making processes.

In the context of municipalities, bylaws are local laws established by local governments or councils. Common municipal bylaw topics include vehicle parking regulations, animal control, building and construction, licensing, noise, zoning, and the management of public recreation areas.

It is worth noting that the process of revising bylaws or a constitution typically involves a thorough review process, including gathering feedback and recommendations from various committees and members, before finalizing and voting on the revisions.

Frequently asked questions

A constitution is a brief document that contains the basic rules and structure of an organization, while bylaws are the detailed, operational rules that govern a corporation's operations.

It is recommended that the constitution and bylaws be combined into a single instrument called the "'bylaws'". If the constitution no longer exists, the replacement of bylaws with new bylaws is called a "revision".

The default process of amending the bylaws is to give previous notice and receive a 2/3 vote or, without notice, gain a majority of the entire membership. However, organizations may include their own amending process in the bylaws.

Bylaws should be revised as needed to reflect changing realities, expectations, and goals.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment