Economic Liberty: Constitutional Protection Or Free Market Fantasy?

does the constitution protect economic liberty

The Constitution of the United States is said to protect economic liberty, which is defined as the right to acquire, use, and possess private property and the right to enter into private contracts of one's choosing. However, some argue that the Constitution does not provide the legal rules that establish private rights to property and contract, nor does it constrain what states and Congress may do when they create, change, and regulate those rights. The First Amendment, for example, was created to protect freedom of speech, but it has also become an important provision in the information economy, protecting businesses that sell information.

Characteristics Values
Economic liberty The right to acquire, use, and possess private property and the right to enter into private contracts of one's choosing
The Constitution protects the rights of private property and contract
The First Amendment protects businesses that sell information
The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment requires equality among citizens

cycivic

The right to acquire, use, and possess private property

The Constitution does not provide the legal rules that establish private rights to property and contract, nor does it constrain what states and Congress may do when they create, change, and regulate those rights. However, the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment has been found to contain powerful constitutional safeguards for economic freedom, requiring equality among citizens.

The First Amendment, while not created with the intention of protecting economic liberty, has become an important provision in the information economy, protecting businesses that sell information.

Economic liberty is deeply ingrained in the Constitution, with the Founders intending for many overlapping sections to provide protection for occupational freedom.

cycivic

The right to enter into private contracts

The First Amendment, for example, was not created to protect economic liberty, but it has become an important provision in the information economy, protecting businesses that sell information.

The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment has been interpreted as providing powerful constitutional safeguards for economic freedom, by requiring equality among citizens.

Economic liberty is deeply ingrained in the Constitution, and the Founders intended for there to be overlapping sections to provide protection for occupational freedom.

cycivic

Occupational freedom

Economic liberty is deeply ingrained in the US Constitution, which was intended to provide protection for occupational freedom. The Constitution protects the rights of private property and contract, which are key components of economic liberty.

The First Amendment, for example, protects businesses that sell information. Other parts of the Constitution also protect these businesses.

However, some argue that the Constitution does not provide the legal rules that establish private rights to property and contract. Instead, it is said that the Constitution indirectly safeguards economic freedom by requiring equality among citizens.

The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment has been interpreted as providing powerful constitutional safeguards for economic freedom.

cycivic

The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment

The concept of economic liberty is deeply rooted in the Constitution, with the Founders intending for multiple overlapping sections to safeguard occupational freedom. This includes the right to acquire, use, and possess private property, as well as the freedom to enter into private contracts of one's choosing. These rights are considered fundamental and are supported by overwhelming evidence within the Constitution.

The Privileges or Immunities Clause, as analysed by Professor Siegan, reinforces these economic liberties by ensuring equality among citizens. This means that all individuals should have equal opportunities to exercise their economic rights, regardless of their background or status. The Clause acts as a safeguard against discrimination or unfair treatment that could hinder economic freedom.

However, it is important to acknowledge that the Constitution does not explicitly provide the legal rules establishing private rights to property and contract. Instead, it serves as a framework that guides and constrains the actions of states and Congress when they create, modify, and regulate these rights. This indirect approach allows for flexibility and adaptation to changing economic circumstances while still upholding the principles of economic liberty.

In conclusion, the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment plays a crucial role in protecting economic freedom within the United States. By promoting equality among citizens and providing an overarching framework for economic rights, this Clause helps ensure that all Americans have the opportunity to pursue their economic endeavours and enjoy the fruits of their labour.

cycivic

The First Amendment

The Constitution protects the right to acquire, use, and possess private property and the right to enter into private contracts. This is defined as 'economic liberty'. The evidence that the Constitution protects these rights is overwhelming.

However, some argue that the Constitution does not provide the legal rules that establish private rights to property and contract. It also does not constrain what states and Congress may do when they create, change, and regulate those rights.

Despite this, economic liberty is deeply ingrained in the Constitution, and the Founders intended for there to be overlapping sections to provide protection for occupational freedom.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, the US Constitution does protect economic liberty. Economic liberty is defined as the right to acquire, use, and possess private property and the right to enter into private contracts of one's choosing.

The evidence that the Constitution protects the rights of private property and contract is overwhelming. The First Amendment, for example, protects businesses that sell information.

The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment has been found to contain powerful constitutional safeguards for economic freedom. This clause operates indirectly, by requiring equality among citizens, and not directly on the substance of state private law.

The purpose of the First Amendment was the protection of speech, not economic liberty. However, it has become an increasingly important provision in the information economy.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment