Bipartisan Agreement: Is Consensus Necessary In Congress?

The United States Congress is made up of the House of Representatives and the Senate, which together hold the sole authority to enact legislation and declare war. Both chambers of Congress have extensive investigative powers, and members of Congress spend much of their time holding hearings and investigations in committee. To enact legislation, both chambers must agree on each and every provision of a bill or joint resolution before it can be submitted to the President for approval or a veto. This agreement is often reached through a Conference Committee, which consists of members from both chambers, or through amendments between the houses.

Explore related products

The Congressional Experience: An Institution Transformed

$39.51 $51.99

Tribal Energy Resource Agreements (TERAs): Approval Process and Selected Issues for Congress

$7.1

Cases in Congressional Campaigns: Split Decision

$41.59 $51.99

Nuclear Cooperation Agreement with Russia: Statutory Procedures for Congressional Consideration and Their Implementation

$0.99

Documentary History of the First Federal Congress of the United States of America, March 4, 1789–March 3, 1791: Correspondence: Second Session, July–October 1790 (Volume 20)

$23.17 $137

Documentary History of the First Federal Congress of the United States of America, March 4, 1789–March 3, 1791: Correspondence: Second Session, October 1789–March 14, 1790 (Volume 18)

$77.54 $137

The US Congress consists of the House of Representatives and the Senate

The Senate, on the other hand, is designed to be a stabilizing counterbalance, with six-year terms for its members. It has certain powers that it maintains independently of the House, such as ratifying treaties by a two-thirds supermajority vote and confirming the appointments of the President by a majority vote. The House of Representatives also has a unique role in the ratification of trade agreements and the confirmation of the Vice President.

Both chambers of Congress have extensive investigative powers and can compel the production of evidence or testimony. They also have the authority to confirm or reject many Presidential appointments. While the two chambers often work independently, there are times when their agreement is necessary. For instance, when submitting a bill or joint resolution to the President, both the Senate and the House of Representatives must agree on every provision of that measure. This includes agreeing on identical legislative language, as minor details can significantly impact a bill's interpretation and implementation.

To facilitate agreement between the two chambers, methods such as conference committees and amendments between the houses are employed. Conference committees, consisting of members from both chambers, negotiate to produce a version of the bill acceptable to both sides. Amendments between the houses involve the two chambers proposing alternatives or insisting on their positions, with the hope that an agreement can be reached.

The House and Senate must agree on the same bill before it becomes law

The United States Congress is made up of two chambers: the House of Representatives and the Senate. Together, these two bodies form the legislative branch of the US federal government and are responsible for enacting legislation. As such, both the House and the Senate must agree on the same bill before it can become law.

The process by which a bill becomes a law typically begins with a bill being introduced and considered in a subcommittee, where it may be accepted, amended, or rejected. If the bill is accepted, it is then reported to the full committee, where the process is repeated. Throughout this stage, committees and subcommittees hold hearings to investigate the merits and flaws of the bill, inviting experts, advocates, and opponents to provide testimony.

Once a bill has been approved by the relevant committees, it must then be passed by both the House and the Senate. This can be achieved through an exchange of amendments between the two chambers, with each house having one opportunity to amend the amendments from the other. In some cases, a Conference Committee, consisting of members from both chambers, may be convened to negotiate a version of the bill that is acceptable to both sides.

It is important to note that it is not sufficient for the two chambers to simply pass separate bills with the same text or comparable purposes. The Constitution requires that the House and Senate approve the exact same bill, with identical language, before it can be presented to the President for signature or veto. This ensures that any legislation enacted into law has been thoroughly considered and agreed upon by both sides of Congress.

Amendments are exchanged between the House and Senate to reach an agreement

The United States Congress is made up of the House of Representatives and the Senate. Both chambers of Congress have extensive investigative powers and may compel the production of evidence or testimony. The Constitution grants Congress the authority to enact legislation and declare war, as well as the right to confirm or reject Presidential appointments.

Before Congress can submit a bill or joint resolution to the President, the Senate and the House of Representatives must agree on every provision of that measure. This means that both chambers must pass the same bill, with identical legislative language. The Constitution requires that the House and Senate approve the same bill or joint resolution in precisely the same form before it is presented to the President for signature or veto.

Amendments are often exchanged between the House and Senate to reach an agreement. Each house has one opportunity to amend the amendments from the other house, so there can be Senate amendments to House amendments and vice versa. The two houses shuttle the measure back and forth, each proposing an alternative to the other's position or insisting on its own position. This process continues until both houses agree on the same position.

In practice, the House often disposes of amendments between the houses under the terms of a special rule reported by the Rules Committee. The House may also act initially on its own bill and then on the Senate's bill on the same subject. In these cases, the House debates, amends, and passes its own bill, and then takes up the counterpart Senate bill. The floor manager moves to strike out the opening lines of the Senate bill and replace them with the full text of the House bill.

Explore related products

Documentary History of the First Federal Congress of the United States of America, March 4, 1789-March 3, 1791: Correspondence: First Session, June - August 1789, Volume 16

$137

A Consensus Handbook: Co-operative decision-making for activists, co-ops and communities

$9.98 $9.99

Congressional Procedure: A Practical Guide to the Legislative Process in the U.S. Congress: The House of Representatives and Senate Explained

$42.7 $21

The Adaptability Paradox: Political Inclusion and Constitutional Resilience (Chicago Studies in American Politics)

$26 $25.99

L'évolution du processus législatif de l'Union européenne: Conflictualité, consensus et tendances sectorielles - n°58 de Politique Européenne (French Edition)

$18.86

Consensus and Controversies in Animal Biotechnology: An Interactive Legislative Approach to Animal Biotechnology in Denmark, Switzerland, and the Netherlands

$56.68 $90

Conference Committees are formed to negotiate versions of bills acceptable to both chambers

Conference Committees are an essential part of the legislative process in the United States, formed with the specific purpose of negotiating and reconciling differences between two versions of a bill, to create a single, unified piece of legislation. The Conference Committee process is initiated when the House and Senate pass two different versions of a bill, and these differences must be resolved before the bill can be sent to the President for their signature.

The Conference Committee is a temporary, ad-hoc panel, made up of members from both the House and the Senate, known as "conferees". The conferees are appointed by the leadership of both chambers, and they work to negotiate and reconcile the two versions of the bill. The committee includes members of both political parties, reflecting the makeup of the chambers. The conferees are given instructions to guide their negotiations, but these are non-binding, and they have flexibility in how they negotiate. It is important to note that the committee can only consider the subjects and provisions within the two bills that are in disagreement.

The Conference Committee process is designed to be efficient and focused. Unlike standing committees, conference committees do not hold public hearings or invite testimony from experts. Instead, they move directly into reconciling the differences between the two versions of the bill. The committee produces a single, consensus bill, known as the "'conference report'", which is then sent back to both chambers for approval. This final version cannot be amended and is voted on as it is, in an "up or down" vote in each chamber.

The Conference Committee process is an important mechanism to ensure that both chambers of Congress can come to an agreement on legislation, and it plays a crucial role in the creation of laws that serve the interests of all Americans.

The House and Senate have investigative powers and can hold hearings and investigations

The United States Congress is made up of the House of Representatives and the Senate, established by Article I of the Constitution. Although the Constitution does not expressly authorise Congress to conduct investigations, Congress and the courts have long recognised that Congress has an inherent, constitutional prerogative to do so. This prerogative is implied by Congress possessing "all legislative powers".

Congressional investigations are central to the system of checks and balances, and can help uncover presidential abuses of power and corruption. The House of Representatives first used its investigatory privileges in the First Congress (1789-1791) when Robert Morris of Pennsylvania, the superintendent of finances during the Continental Congress, asked Congress to investigate his handling of the country's finances to clear his name of potential impropriety. The first congressional investigation occurred in 1792 when the House of Representatives convened a committee to investigate the defeat of General Arthur St. Clair in the Battle of the Wabash.

Congress has the authority to conduct investigations "in aid of its legislative function". This authority can extend to investigations for deciding whether legislation is appropriate, information gathering on matters of national importance, and oversight of federal departments and executive agencies. Congressional investigations can take the form of hearings, which are most commonly held to consider pending legislation, to investigate issues that may require future legislation, and to investigate and oversee federal programs.

Congress's authority to investigate is broad but not unlimited. It is tied to its authority to legislate, and so limits on congressional investigations are linked to the limits on Congress's constitutional authority. For example, Congress cannot investigate the private affairs of an ordinary citizen, nor can it investigate matters committed to the President's discretion.

Frequently asked questions